Sunday, August 21, 2005
Lee Kuan Yew in Der Spiegel
Lee Kuan Yew is a personality who I find myself conflicted about. I find his dictatorial tendencies (some of which linger in Singapore today) absoloutely abhorrent. At the same time, there is no denying that he was a brilliant thinker who turned a piece of real estate that neither the Brits nor the Malaysians really wanted into one of the most advanced economies of the world. Though he has retired from active politics, you can see glimpses of his political astuteness in this interview with Der Sipegel. Most of the interview is devoted to the rise of China and its consequences.
Where does this rapid growth in India and China leave Singapore? Where does S'pore's competitive advantage lie?
Lee's advice to European governments?
Chinese relations with Taiwan?
Advice to North Korea?
Read the whole thing. It's excellent.
What is gradually happening is the restoration of the world balance to what it was in the early 19th century or late 18th century when China and India together were responsible for more than 40 percent of world GDP. With those two countries becoming part of the globalized trading world, they are going to go back to approximately the level of world GDP that they previously occupied. But that doesn't make them the superpowers of the world.
Economically, there will be a shift to the Pacific from the Atlantic Ocean and you can already see that in the shipping volumes of Chinese ports. Every shipping line is trying to get into association with a Chinese container port. India is slower because their infrastructure is still to be completed. But I think they will join in the race, build roads, bridges, airports, container ports and they'll become a manufacturing hub. Raw materials go in, finished goods go out.
Where does this rapid growth in India and China leave Singapore? Where does S'pore's competitive advantage lie?
Such as where the rule of law, intellectual property and security of production systems are required, because for them to establish that, it will take 20 to 30 years. We are concentrating on bio medicine, pharmaceuticals and all products requiring protection of intellectual property rights. No pharmaceutical company is going to go have its precious patents disclosed. So that is why they are here in Singapore and not in China.
Lee's advice to European governments?
Every year, our unions and the Labour Department subsidize trips to China and India. We tell the participants: Don't just look at the Great Wall but go to the factories and ask, "What are you paid?" What hours do you work?" And they come back shell-shocked. The Chinese had perestroika first, then glasnost. That's where the Russians made their mistake.
Chinese relations with Taiwan?
Their objective is to raise the level of damage they can deliver to the Americans if they intervene in Taiwan. Their objective is not to defeat the Americans, which they cannot do. They know they will be defeated. They want to weaken the American resolve to intervene. That is their objective, but they do not want to attack Taiwan. I think they have put themselves into a position internationally that if Taiwan declares independence, they must react and if Beijing's leadership doesn't, they would be finished, they would be a paper tiger and they know that. So, they passed the anti-secession law to tell the Taiwanese and the Americans and the Japanese, "I do not want to fight, but if you allow Taiwan to go for independence, I will have to fight." I think the anti-secession law is a law to preserve the status quo.
Advice to North Korea?
If I were Kim I would freeze the programme, tell the Americans you can inspect, but if you attack me, I will use it. That leaves the Americans with the problem of checking and verifying and intercepting ships, aircraft, endless problems.
Read the whole thing. It's excellent.