<$BlogRSDUrl$>

Monday, December 13, 2004

How birthrates color the electoral map 

[From Eugene Letuchy] Steve Sailer writes The American Conservative magazine cover story on the correlation between Bush's vote in 2004 with the white total fertility rate. Given the degree to which the swing states affected the campaigns and the outcome in this election, overall nation-wide statistics might not appear very significant, but lost in the arguments about the role of values in Ohio might be the role of nation-wide demographic trends. The degree of correlation is remarkably high (0.86), even if the statistical sample is small. Steve Sailer argues why the correlation might be more than statistical.

Bush carried the 19 states with the highest white fertility (just as he did in 2000), and 25 out of the top 26, with highly unionized Michigan being the one blue exception to the rule. (The least prolific red states are West Virginia, North Dakota, and Florida.)

Couples attempting to raise children in a big blue city quickly learn the truth of what bond trader Sherman McCoy’s father told him in Tom Wolfe’s Bonfire of the Vanities: "If you want to live in New York, you’ve got to insulate, insulate, insulate." Manhattan liberals all believe in celebrating diversity in theory but typically draw the line at subjecting their own offspring to it in the public schools. With Manhattan private K-12 school tuitions now approaching $25,000, insulating multiple children rapidly becomes too expensive for all but the filthy rich.

The late socialist historian Jim Chapin pointed out that it was perfectly rational for parents with more children than money to ask their political and cultural leaders to help them insulate their kids from bad examples, even, or perhaps especially, if the parents themselves are not perfect role models.